BigCommerce Standard sits at the same $39/mo price tier as Shopify Basic but charges no platform transaction fees, which over a $100K revenue year saves $2,000-$3,000 versus Shopify Payments and more against third-party processors. The cost flips when app-catalog depth, small-catalog economics, digital-only product mix, or design-led brand presentation is the actual constraint.
Where alternatives win
Shopify Basic matches BigCommerce on entry subscription but charges 2.9% + 30c on cards; pays back through the largest app catalog and best-converting checkout in hosted ecommerce.
Ecwid Venture undercuts BigCommerce by roughly half and plugs into an existing site (WordPress, Wix, Squarespace, custom) rather than forcing a full ecommerce-first rebuild.
Lemon Squeezy is purpose-built for digital sellers as merchant-of-record; handles global VAT and sales tax compliance BigCommerce pushes back to you.
Squarespace Commerce Basic ships the most polished visual templates in hosted ecommerce, with the bundled site and blog covering content needs alongside the shop.
By Subrupt EditorialPublished Reviewed
BigCommerce occupies the strongest price-to-feature slot in hosted ecommerce. The Standard tier matches Shopify Basic on subscription, charges no platform-side transaction fees, and ships stronger built-in primitives (B2B Edition, complex pricing, multi-storefront) than peers at the same price tier. For stores doing real volume on a real budget, it is rarely the wrong call.
Where the picks below come in is store shape. If your growth depends on specialized apps that only ship on Shopify, the app-catalog gap matters more than the fee math. If your catalog is fifty products and revenue is small, BigCommerce is over-tooled and Ecwid plugs in at half the cost. If eighty percent of your products are digital, Lemon Squeezy removes the monthly subscription and the global VAT burden in one move. If your storefront is part of the brand, Squarespace's design polish wins.
Four reader groups arrive here. Stores hitting BigCommerce's app-catalog ceiling who need Shopify-grade depth. Small-catalog operators paying for primitives they do not use. Digital-only sellers (courses, software, ebooks) drowning in international tax compliance. And lifestyle or fashion brands where visual presentation is what sells the product.
Quick map by store shape: app-catalog depth equals Shopify. Small-catalog plug-in equals Ecwid. Digital-only with VAT handling equals Lemon Squeezy. Design-led brand presentation equals Squarespace.
Affiliate disclosure: Subrupt earns a commission when you switch to a service through our recommendation links. This never changes the price you pay. We only recommend services where there's a real cost or feature advantage for you, and our picks are based on the data on this page, not on which programs pay the most.
Quick pick by use case
If you only have thirty seconds, find your situation below and skip to that pick.
Shopify Basic at $39/mo + 2.9% + 30c with the largest app catalog, best-converting checkout, and strongest theme and developer mindshare in hosted ecommerce.
Best for small catalogs that keep the existing site
Squarespace Commerce Basic at $36/mo with 0% platform fees and the most polished visual templates in hosted ecommerce.
Skip these picks if: If you depend on the zero-platform-fee model at real revenue, you need B2B Edition or multi-storefront built into the platform, or your store has the kind of complex pricing and shipping rules where BigCommerce's deeper primitives are doing real work, the picks below trade those primitives for app depth, small-catalog economics, or design polish that may not be the lever you actually need.
At a glance: BigCommerce alternatives
Quick comparison across pricing floor, best fit, and switching effort. Tap a row to jump to the full pick.
Best for digital-product creators with print-on-demand
$29/mo, $10K cap
Low
Feature comparison
Feature
Shopify
Ecwid
Lemon Squeezy
Squarespace Commerce
Entry monthly price
$39/mo
$19/mo
$0
$36/mo
Platform transaction feeOn top of payment processing
✓
✗
5% + 50c
✗
App catalog depth
✓
~
✗
~
B2B Edition built in
~
✗
✗
✗
Plugs into existing site
✗
✓
~
✗
Merchant of record (handles VAT)
✗
✗
✓
✗
Free tier
✗
✓
✓
✗
Visual template polish
~
✗
✗
✓
Multi-storefront
~
✗
✗
✗
Cost at your volume
Approximate cost per pick at typical annual revenue.
Pick
Starter25,000 annual revenue
Growing100,000 annual revenue
Scale400,000 annual revenue
Shopify
$1,198/mo
$3,528/mo
$13,608/mo
Ecwid
$953/mo
$3,398/mo
$12,860/mo
Lemon Squeezy
$1,370/mo
$5,120/mo
$20,120/mo
Squarespace Commerce
$1,207/mo
$3,422/mo
$12,260/mo
Modeled at typical card-processing rate (2.9% + 30c) where the platform charges no transaction fee, plus subscription. Lemon Squeezy fees include processing; Ecwid and Squarespace assume Stripe at standard rates.
BigCommerce's biggest gap is its app catalog. It is mature but not Shopify-deep, and stores whose growth hinges on specialized apps (advanced subscription billing, niche fulfillment integrations, marketing tools that only ship on Shopify) eventually feel the ceiling.
The trade: Platform transaction fees on top of subscription. The Pro tier jumps to a steep upper end. B2B features lighter than BigCommerce's built-in B2B Edition.
The upside: Same entry price tier as BigCommerce buys the largest app catalog in hosted ecommerce, the best-converting checkout, and the deepest theme and developer mindshare. For stores past BigCommerce's surface area, Shopify pays itself back quickly through specialized apps and conversion lift.
“We had a terrible experience on BigCommerce, lost time and money over five-plus years. Switched to Shopify and it is a superior service; the app ecosystem alone made it worth the migration.”
“Shopify features almost six times the number of apps and the checkout converts roughly twelve percent better than BigCommerce. Brands switching from BigCommerce get a customizable, one-click checkout that BigCommerce simply does not match.”
Strengths
+Largest app catalog in hosted ecommerce
+Best-converting checkout
+Largest theme catalog and developer mindshare
+Built-in BigCommerce migration tool
Trade-offs
−Platform transaction fees on top of subscription
−Pro tier expensive at the upper end
−B2B features lighter than BigCommerce's built-in B2B Edition
Basic
$39/mo + 2.9% + 30c
Shopify
$105/mo + 2.6% + 30c
Advanced
$399/mo + 2.4% + 30c
Pricing verified
2026-05-07
Migration steps
Export products, customers, and orders from BigCommerce admin (each as a separate CSV).
Use Shopify's Store Importer app, which imports BigCommerce CSVs and preserves product variants.
Rebuild your BigCommerce theme as a Shopify theme; templating languages differ (Stencil vs Liquid).
Switch DNS, set up redirects from old BigCommerce URLs to new Shopify URLs, and monitor 404s for two weeks.
Not for: Skip Shopify if you depend on BigCommerce's zero-platform-fee model at high revenue or you need B2B Edition built into the platform.
Both BigCommerce Standard and Shopify Basic sit at $39/mo and are over-tooled for stores with twenty to one hundred products doing modest volume. Ecwid Venture covers up to one hundred products at roughly half the cost and plugs into an existing site rather than forcing a rebuild.
The trade: Checkout less polished than Shopify. Smaller app catalog than BigCommerce. Marketplace selling features lighter; not a full standalone ecommerce platform.
The upside: For small stores, side projects, or content-led businesses adding a shop, Ecwid is the right shape and roughly half the price. The Free tier covers five products, the Venture tier covers one hundred, and the widget embeds anywhere (WordPress, Wix, Squarespace, custom) so the existing site stays intact.
Strengths
+Roughly half BigCommerce's entry-tier price
+Free tier covers 5 products
+Plugs into any existing site (WordPress, Wix, Squarespace, custom)
+No platform transaction fees
Trade-offs
−Checkout less polished than Shopify
−Smaller app catalog than BigCommerce
−Marketplace selling features lighter
Free
5 products
Venture
$19/mo, 100 products
Business
$39/mo, 2,500 products
Pricing verified
2026-05-07
Migration steps
Export BigCommerce products and customers via admin > Export.
Sign up for Ecwid (Free tier handles up to 5 products, paid plans scale up).
Import the CSV via Catalog > Products > Import.
Embed the Ecwid widget where your BigCommerce storefront was, or set up Ecwid's Instant Site.
Not for: Skip Ecwid if you want a real standalone ecommerce platform; Ecwid is a widget for adding a store to an existing site.
If eighty percent of your catalog is digital products (courses, ebooks, software, templates, music), the BigCommerce subscription is overhead you do not need. Lemon Squeezy ships as merchant-of-record with no monthly fee on Free and handles global VAT and sales tax compliance you would otherwise own yourself.
The trade: Not for physical product catalogs. Storefront customization more limited than BigCommerce. Per-transaction fees compound at high volume; the math flips back to a subscription platform somewhere around six-figure annual revenue. Stripe acquired Lemon Squeezy in 2024 and the team confirmed in January 2026 it is now in transition toward Stripe Managed Payments, with slower support and fewer product updates during the migration.
The upside: Merchant-of-record removes the international tax burden entirely. Subscriptions, license keys, and trial flows are built in. For sub-$100K digital-only catalogs the no-monthly-fee model is rarely beaten on simplicity.
“LemonSqueezy automatically calculates, collects, and remits sales tax and VAT globally. Whether your customer is in the UK, the EU, or a specific US state, the platform handles the filing. The 5% + 50c fee critics flag is high versus Stripe base rate, but for small-to-medium digital teams the automation saves more than it costs.”
Strengths
+Merchant-of-record handles global VAT and sales tax
+No monthly fee on Free tier
+Built for digital products, courses, and SaaS
+Subscriptions and license keys built in
Trade-offs
−Not for physical product catalogs
−Storefront customization more limited
−Per-transaction fees compound at high volume
−Stripe Managed Payments migration adds uncertainty through 2026
Free
5% + 50c
Growth
$10/mo, 3.5% + 50c
Merchant of record
Yes (global VAT)
Pricing verified
2026-05-07
Migration steps
Export your digital products and customer list from BigCommerce.
Open a Lemon Squeezy account and configure your store and tax settings.
Upload your products; Lemon Squeezy handles VAT and merchant-of-record complexity.
Switch your checkout links to Lemon Squeezy, then disable the old BigCommerce listings.
Not for: Skip Lemon Squeezy if you sell physical products, or if the Stripe Managed Payments transition timeline is a blocker for your launch window.
BigCommerce templates are functional rather than brand-led. For lifestyle brands, fashion, art, and small-batch makers where the storefront is part of the product, Squarespace Commerce Basic is the natural pick.
The trade: Smaller app catalog than BigCommerce. Lighter on B2B and complex pricing rules. Less developer-friendly when you need a headless or API-driven backend.
The upside: Cheapest of the four picks here, with the most polished visual templates in hosted ecommerce, the bundled site and blog covering content needs, and 0% platform transaction fees. For brands where presentation sells the product, the design polish is doing real work.
Strengths
+Most polished visual templates in hosted ecommerce
+Bundled site, blog, and shop
+0% platform transaction fees on Commerce plans
+Strongest for visual brand-first storefronts
Trade-offs
−Smaller app catalog than BigCommerce
−Lighter on B2B and complex pricing rules
−Less developer-friendly for headless setups
Commerce Basic
$36/mo
Commerce Advanced
$65/mo
Transaction fee
0% on Commerce plans
Pricing verified
2026-05-07
Migration steps
Export your BigCommerce products and orders as CSV.
Open a Squarespace account and pick a Commerce plan.
Pick a Squarespace template close to your current store design.
Import the products CSV, configure shipping, and switch DNS once everything is verified.
Not for: Skip Squarespace Commerce if you need a real headless or API-driven ecommerce backend; Squarespace's commerce is design-first, not engineering-first.
Sellfy is shaped specifically for creators selling digital downloads, print-on-demand merch, or subscriptions to a small audience. Starter at $29/mo covers $10K in annual sales with custom domain and 0% transaction fees on the Sellfy side.
The trade: Annual sales caps per tier ($10K, $50K, $200K) force tier upgrades as you grow. Smaller catalog than BigCommerce. Storefront customization is fixed-template; the design surface is small.
The upside: Cheapest path off Gumroad's 10% flat fee for creators who have outgrown it but are not yet at BigCommerce volume. Built-in email marketing, subscriptions, and POD integration mean fewer paid add-ons. The annual plan saves about a quarter versus monthly.
Strengths
+Shaped for digital and print-on-demand creators
+Custom domain on Starter
+0% transaction fees on Sellfy side
+Built-in email marketing
Trade-offs
−Annual sales caps per tier ($10K, $50K, $200K)
−Smaller catalog than BigCommerce
−Less suited to physical-only operations
Starter
$29/mo, $10K cap
Business
$79/mo, $50K cap
Premium
$159/mo, $200K cap
Pricing verified
2026-05-07
Migration steps
Export your products and customers from BigCommerce.
Open a Sellfy account and pick the tier matching your annual revenue.
Import your catalog via the product CSV importer.
Switch your sales links to Sellfy URLs, then disable the old BigCommerce listings.
Not for: Skip Sellfy if you need deep customization; Sellfy's storefront is fixed-template and the design surface is small.
Paid plans from $29.00/mo
When to stay with BigCommerce
Stay with BigCommerce if you depend on the zero-platform-fee model at real revenue, your catalog needs B2B Edition (customer groups, custom price lists, bulk pricing) built in, you run multi-storefront from one admin, or your store has hit the kind of complex shipping and pricing rules where the deeper primitives pay for themselves. The picks below are honest exits for stores whose constraint is app-catalog depth, small-catalog price math, digital-only product mix, or design-led brand presentation.
BigCommerce alternatives are scored on the actual constraint that drives switching: app-catalog depth, small-catalog price math, digital-only product mix with global tax handling, and design-led brand presentation. Each pick is the lead choice for one of those constraints.
Pricing is taken from each vendor's site on the review date and re-checked quarterly. The Usage Cost Table assumes typical card processing (2.9% + 30c) on platforms that charge no platform fee; Lemon Squeezy's 5% + 50c includes processing.
Update history2 updates
Initial published version with 5 picks.
Backfilled to Stage 2 schema with structured verdict, 4-paragraph intro, Quick Verdict, Feature Matrix, Usage Cost Table, sourced testimonials, and per-pick author ratings. Pricing verified against each vendor's site: BigCommerce Standard $39/mo monthly or $29/mo annual, Plus $105/$79, Pro $399/$299, all with 0% platform fees; Shopify Basic $39/mo + 2.9% + 30c; Ecwid Venture $19/mo; Lemon Squeezy 5% + 50c with $10 Growth (now in Stripe Managed Payments transition after January 2026 update); Squarespace Commerce Basic $36/mo; Sellfy Starter $29/mo with $10K annual cap. Added missing bigcommerce->shopify derived row so the first pick renders.
Frequently asked questions about BigCommerce alternatives
Why does BigCommerce charge no platform transaction fees?
It is the platform's pricing differentiator. Revenue comes from subscription tiers and Enterprise contracts. Processing fees are paid directly to whichever gateway you choose, so BigCommerce never takes a cut on top.
Is BigCommerce really cheaper than Shopify long-term?
For high-volume stores using Shopify Payments, the gap narrows because Shopify's processing is reasonably priced. For stores using third-party processors on Shopify, BigCommerce wins by 1.5 to 2 percent of revenue per year, which compounds at six-figure revenue.
How does the B2B feature set compare?
BigCommerce B2B Edition (built into Plus and above) covers customer groups, custom price lists, and bulk pricing without add-ons. Shopify needs paid B2B apps to reach parity. For real B2B work, BigCommerce wins on built-in features.
Can I migrate my BigCommerce store to Shopify?
Yes. Shopify ships a built-in BigCommerce migration that covers products, customers, and order history. Apps and themes need rebuilding because the templating languages differ (Stencil vs Liquid); budget one to two weeks plus parallel running.
What about Magento or Adobe Commerce?
Magento is open source and self-hosted. Adobe Commerce is the hosted version, priced for enterprise. Both are credible at multi-million revenue scale; below that, BigCommerce or Shopify cover the same workload at far lower total cost of ownership.
Ready to switch?
Our top BigCommerce alternative: Shopify
Shopify Basic matches BigCommerce on entry subscription but charges 2.9% + 30c on cards; pays back through the largest app catalog and best-converting checkout in hosted ecommerce.
The team behind subrupt.com. We track subscriptions, surface cheaper alternatives, and publish comparisons where the score formula is on the page so you can recompute it yourself. We do not claim 30,000 hours of testing. What we claim is live pricing from our database, a transparent composite score, and honest savings math against a category baseline.
Get notified of price drops for BigCommerce
We'll email you when BigCommerce or its alternatives lower their prices.
Track BigCommerce and find more savings
Add BigCommerce to your dashboard to monitor spending and discover even more alternatives.