M1 Finance
4.5/10Best hybrid robo-advisor with pie-based self-directed control
Pie-based auto-rebalancing with self-directed allocation control; hybrid robo plus manual brokerage in one account.
| Plan | Monthly | What you get |
|---|---|---|
| M1 (free) | Free | Pie-based portfolio investing with auto-rebalancing across user-defined slice allocations; $0 trades and fractional shares for any ETF or stock |
| M1 Plus (optional) | Free | $10 a month or $95 a year optional subscription with custom AM trading window, smart transfers, and 5-plus percent APY checking |
M1 Finance is the right pick when the goal is auto-rebalancing infrastructure with self-directed allocation control rather than fully delegated robo management. Founded in 2015, M1 built around the pie metaphor where users set their own target allocations as percentage slices and the platform automatically rebalances new contributions toward the targets.
The wedge for robo-advisor readers is the hybrid model. Where Wealthfront and Betterment fully delegate allocation decisions to algorithms, M1 keeps the user in control of the pie composition while automating the rebalancing and contribution-direction mechanics. Users build their own pie or pick from expert pies (Bogleheads three-fund, target-date glidepath, dividend income). Fractional shares supported throughout.
The trade-off is tax-loss harvesting and goal-based planning. M1 lacks the daily tax-loss harvesting Wealthfront ships and the goal-based planning depth Betterment provides; the platform is auto-rebalancing infrastructure rather than full robo management. Choose M1 when self-directed pie allocation matters and you want auto-rebalancing without delegating allocation decisions; choose Wealthfront or Betterment for full robo delegation.
Pros
- Pie-based portfolio metaphor with user-controlled allocation and auto-rebalancing
- Expert pies for Bogleheads three-fund, target-date, and dividend-income strategies
- Hybrid robo plus manual brokerage; switch between auto-investing and self-directed in one account
- Founded 2015; the most-developed pie-portfolio auto-investing platform at scale
- Roth IRA and Traditional IRA accounts supported alongside taxable brokerage
Cons
- No daily tax-loss harvesting; auto-rebalancing only
- No goal-based planning interface comparable to Wealthfront Path or Betterment goals
Best for: Investors who want auto-rebalancing infrastructure with self-directed pie allocation control rather than fully delegated robo management.
- Trust
- 8
- Cost
- 7
- UX
- 9
- Value
- 9
- Support
- 7