Skip to content

Best Non-Profit Fundraisings of 2026

Updated · 7 picks · live pricing · affiliate disclosure

Free platform with optional tip-or-fee and 0% platform fee since 2017.

BEST OVERALL8.8/10Save $2,052/yr

Givebutter

Free platform with optional tip-or-fee and 0% platform fee since 2017.

Free platform with optional donor tip model

How it stacks up

  • Free 0% platform

    vs Donorbox 1.5%

  • Plus $29/mo

    vs Bloomerang per-record

  • Founded 2017

    vs Classy P2P

#2
Donorbox8.8/10

From $19/mo

View
#3
Bloomerang6.5/10

From $99/mo

View

All picks at a glance

#PickBest forStartingFreeScore
1GivebutterBest free platform with optional tip-or-fee model since 2017$29.00/mo8.8/10
2DonorboxBest affordable online giving with payment-fees-only model since 2014$19.00/mo8.8/10
3BloomerangBest mainstream donor management with broadest mid-market base since 2012$99.00/mo6.5/10
4DonorPerfectBest per-record-priced mid-market donor mgmt with auction plus event modules$99.00/mo6.4/10
5BonterraBest legacy enterprise consolidation with Network for Good plus EveryAction$159.00/mo4.2/10
6ClassyBest peer-to-peer enterprise fundraising with GoFundMe acquisition since 2022$199.00/mo4.0/10
7Kindful (Bloomerang-acquired 2021)Best Bloomerang-acquired mid-market donor management since 2021$119.00/mo2.9/10

Quick pick by use case

If you only have thirty seconds, find your situation below and skip to that pick.

Compare all 7 picks

Free tierTop spec
#1Givebutter8.8/10$29.00/mo$348.00/yrSave $2,052/yrFree 0% platform
#2Donorbox8.8/10$19.00/mo$228.00/yrSave $2,172/yrFree 1.5% + Stripe
#3Bloomerang6.5/10$199.00/mo$2,388.00/yrSave $12/yrEssentials $99/mo
#4DonorPerfect6.4/10$179.00/mo$2,148.00/yrSave $252/yrLite $99/mo
#5Bonterra4.2/10$500.00/mo$6,000.00/yr$3,600/yr moreGuided $159/mo
#6Classy4.0/10$499.00/mo$5,988.00/yr$3,588/yr moreEssentials $199/mo
#7Kindful (Bloomerang-acquired 2021)2.9/10$419.00/mo$5,028.00/yr$2,628/yr moreEssentials $119/mo
#1

Givebutter

8.8/10Save $2,052/yr

Best free platform with optional tip-or-fee model since 2017

Free platform with optional tip-or-fee and 0% platform fee since 2017.

PlanMonthlyAnnualWhat you get
FreeFreeFree platform with optional tip-or-fee, 0% platform fee, donor CRM, and giving forms.
Plus$29.00/mo$348.00/yrPer-month Plus at $29/mo for 5k contacts with email, texting, workflows, and custom branding.
Premium$249.00/mo$2,988.00/yrPer-month Premium at $249/mo with unlimited contacts, phone outreach, advanced segmentation, and API.

Givebutter is the free-platform tip-or-fee non-profit fundraising platform for SMB nonprofits whose evaluation centers on zero-platform-fee giving with optional donor-tipping to fund Givebutter. Founded 2017 in Washington DC, Givebutter built around the thesis that nonprofits should not pay platform fees that reduce donor giving; the platform offers 0% platform fee with optional donor tip (which most donors accept) to fund Givebutter operations.

Three tiers. Free is 0% platform fee with optional donor tip-or-fee model, donor CRM, and giving forms. Plus is $29/mo for 5k contacts with email, texting, workflows, and custom branding. Premium is $249/mo with unlimited contacts, phone outreach, advanced segmentation, and API.

The load-bearing wedge is the 0% platform fee plus the optional donor tip model. Where Bloomerang, Classy, and Bonterra charge per-record-tier monthly and Donorbox charges 1.5% platform fee, Givebutter charges 0% platform with the donor-tip model that funds operations; for SMB nonprofits whose donor base accepts tips, Givebutter delivers the highest net-to-mission ratio. The catch is the donor-tip model only works if donors actually tip; nonprofits whose donor base declines tips end up paying via the optional platform fee instead.

Pros

  • 0% platform fee with optional donor tip model
  • Plus $29/mo with email plus texting plus workflows
  • Custom branding plus custom domain on Plus
  • Donor CRM plus giving forms bundled on Free
  • Strong fit for SMB nonprofits whose donor base accepts tips

Cons

  • Donor tip model only works if donors actually tip
  • No SAML SSO or Salesforce integration on free or paid tiers
Free 0% platformPlus $29/moFounded 2017Free platform with optional donor tip model

Best for: SMB nonprofits whose donor base accepts optional tips wanting 0% platform fee plus Plus $29/mo for email plus texting workflows.

Donor data residency
9
Donation processing latency
10
Volunteer plus staff adoption curve
10
Value
10
Support
9
#2

Donorbox

8.8/10Save $2,172/yr

Best affordable online giving with payment-fees-only model since 2014

Affordable online giving with 1.5% Donorbox fee plus Stripe processing only since 2014.

PlanMonthlyAnnualWhat you get
FreeFreeFree platform with payment-processing fees only (1.5% Donorbox + Stripe fees) and donation forms.
Pro$19.00/mo$228.00/yrPer-month Pro at $19/mo with 0% Donorbox platform fee, advanced reporting, and integrations.
Premium$79.00/mo$948.00/yrPer-month Premium at $79/mo with peer-to-peer, events, and Mailchimp plus QuickBooks integrations.
Enterprise$500.00/mo$6,000.00/yrCustom-quoted Enterprise with dedicated infrastructure, SSO, audit, and dedicated CSM.

Donorbox is the affordable online giving platform for SMB nonprofits whose evaluation centers on the cheapest published per-month entry plus payment-fees-only model. Founded 2014 in San Francisco, Donorbox built around the thesis that SMB nonprofits should ship online giving at $19/mo Pro with 0% platform fee rather than per-record or transaction-percentage models.

Four tiers. Free is 1.5% Donorbox + 2.9% Stripe with donation forms, recurring giving, and donor management. Pro is $19/mo with 0% platform fee, advanced reporting, and integrations plus custom branding. Premium is $79/mo with peer-to-peer plus events plus Mailchimp plus QuickBooks integrations. Enterprise is custom-quoted at $500+/mo with dedicated infrastructure, SSO, and dedicated CSM.

The load-bearing wedge is the cheapest published Pro tier plus payment-fees-only Free model. Where Bloomerang, Classy, Bonterra, and Kindful charge $99-$1K monthly per-record and Givebutter charges 0% platform with optional tips, Donorbox Pro at $19/mo eliminates platform fee at the cheapest published per-month rate; for SMB nonprofits with under 1k donors and predictable volume, Donorbox Pro is the cheapest published path. The catch is the Premium $79/mo tier limits feature ceiling vs Bloomerang Standard.

Pros

  • Pro $19/mo with 0% Donorbox platform fee (cheapest published per-month)
  • Free tier with 1.5% Donorbox + Stripe payment-fees-only
  • Premium $79/mo with peer-to-peer plus events
  • Mailchimp plus QuickBooks integrations on Premium
  • Strong fit for SMB nonprofits with under 1k donors

Cons

  • Premium $79/mo tier limits feature ceiling vs Bloomerang Standard
  • No SAML SSO on Free or Pro tiers (Premium has SSO add-on)
Free 1.5% + StripePro $19/moFounded 2014Free with 1.5% Donorbox + Stripe processing fees

Best for: SMB nonprofits with under 1k donors wanting cheapest published Pro $19/mo with 0% platform fee plus Stripe payment-fees-only model.

Donor data residency
9
Donation processing latency
10
Volunteer plus staff adoption curve
10
Value
10
Support
9
#3

Bloomerang

6.5/10Save $12/yr

Best mainstream donor management with broadest mid-market base since 2012

Mainstream donor management with broadest mid-market non-profit reference base since 2012.

PlanMonthlyAnnualWhat you get
Free TrialFreeFree demo plus trial period with donor database, giving forms, and basic email plus reports.
Essentials$99.00/mo$1,188.00/yrPer-record Essentials at $99/mo for up to 1k records with donor management, email, and giving.
Standard$199.00/mo$2,388.00/yrPer-record Standard at $199/mo for up to 5k records with engagement scoring and workflows.
Pro$499.00/mo$5,988.00/yrCustom-quoted Pro at $499+/mo for 25k+ records with API, custom dashboards, and volunteer management.

Bloomerang is the mainstream donor management platform for mid-market nonprofits whose evaluation centers on the broadest mid-market reference base plus engagement scoring. Founded 2012 in Indianapolis and now bundling Kindful (acquired 2021), Bloomerang built around the thesis that nonprofit donor management should ship donor database plus email plus giving plus engagement scoring as one platform with the deepest mid-market nonprofit reference base.

Four tiers. Free Trial covers demo plus trial period with donor database, giving forms, and basic email plus reports. Essentials is $99/mo for up to 1k records with donor management, email, and giving. Standard is $199/mo for up to 5k records with engagement scoring and workflows. Pro is custom-quoted at $499+/mo for 25k+ records with API, custom dashboards, and volunteer management.

The load-bearing wedge is the broadest mid-market nonprofit reference base plus the engagement-scoring depth. Where DonorPerfect ships per-record-priced and Classy targets peer-to-peer enterprise and Givebutter plus Donorbox target SMB free entry, Bloomerang covers the broadest mid-market segment with the donor management playbook that nonprofits adopt as the standard. The catch is the per-record pricing climbs above 25k records and Bloomerang's auction plus event modules are lighter than DonorPerfect Premier.

Pros

  • Broadest mid-market nonprofit reference base since 2012
  • Engagement scoring plus workflows on Standard tier
  • Bundled Kindful since 2021 acquisition for mid-market consolidation
  • QuickBooks plus Mailchimp integrations
  • Strong fit for mid-market nonprofits with 1k-25k donor records

Cons

  • Per-record pricing climbs above 25k records
  • Auction plus event modules lighter than DonorPerfect Premier
Essentials $99/moStandard $199/moFounded 2012Free demo plus trial period with giving forms

Best for: Mid-market nonprofits with 1k-25k donor records wanting broadest reference base plus engagement scoring with mid-market peer plus event workflows.

Donor data residency
9
Donation processing latency
9
Volunteer plus staff adoption curve
10
Value
8
Support
9
#4

DonorPerfect

6.4/10Save $252/yr

Best per-record-priced mid-market donor mgmt with auction plus event modules

Per-record-priced mid-market donor management with auction plus event modules since 1999.

PlanMonthlyAnnualWhat you get
Free TrialFreeFree demo with sample data, donor records, reports, online giving, and email.
Lite$99.00/mo$1,188.00/yrPer-record Lite at $99/mo for 2 users plus 1k records with donor management and online forms.
Express$179.00/mo$2,148.00/yrPer-record Express at $179/mo for 4 users plus 10k records with email marketing and workflows.
Premier$369.00/mo$4,428.00/yrPer-record Premier at $369/mo for 10 users plus 25k records with auction and event modules.
Enterprise$699.00/mo$8,388.00/yrCustom-quoted Enterprise at $699+/mo with unlimited records, custom roles, and dedicated CSM.

DonorPerfect is the per-record-priced mid-market donor management platform for nonprofits whose evaluation centers on per-record published pricing plus bundled auction and event modules. Founded 1999 in Horsham, Pennsylvania (SofterWare), DonorPerfect built around the thesis that mid-market nonprofits should ship donor management with auction plus event modules bundled rather than as separate vendors; the Premier tier bundles auction plus event modules.

Five tiers. Free Trial covers demo plus sample data with donor records, reports, online giving, and email. Lite is $99/mo for 2 users plus 1k records with donor management and online forms. Express is $179/mo for 4 users plus 10k records with email marketing and workflows. Premier is $369/mo for 10 users plus 25k records with auction plus event modules. Enterprise is custom-quoted at $699+/mo with unlimited records and dedicated CSM.

The load-bearing wedge is the per-record published pricing plus the bundled auction-plus-event modules. Where Bloomerang ships engagement scoring without bundled auction modules and Classy ships peer-to-peer enterprise, DonorPerfect ships per-record published with bundled auction-plus-event on Premier; for mid-market nonprofits running material auctions or events, DonorPerfect's bundle eliminates a separate auction vendor. The catch is the SofterWare-backed product roadmap is older than Bloomerang's modern UX.

Pros

  • Per-record published pricing across Lite, Express, Premier tiers
  • Auction plus event modules bundled on Premier $369/mo
  • SofterWare backing since 1999 for risk-averse procurement
  • Email marketing plus workflows on Express
  • Strong fit for mid-market nonprofits running material auctions or events

Cons

  • SofterWare-backed product roadmap older than Bloomerang modern UX
  • No native peer-to-peer fundraising (Classy plus Givebutter ship P2P)
Lite $99/moPremier $369/moFounded 1999Free demo with sample data plus donor records

Best for: Mid-market nonprofits running material auctions or events wanting per-record published pricing plus bundled auction-plus-event modules.

Donor data residency
9
Donation processing latency
9
Volunteer plus staff adoption curve
8
Value
9
Support
9
#5

Bonterra

4.2/10$3,600/yr more

Best legacy enterprise consolidation with Network for Good plus EveryAction

Legacy enterprise consolidation of Network for Good plus EveryAction plus Social Solutions since 2022.

PlanMonthlyAnnualWhat you get
Guided Fundraising$159.00/mo$1,908.00/yrCustom-quoted Guided Fundraising at ~$159/mo (formerly Network for Good) with donor management and giving.
Development + Marketing CRM$500.00/mo$6,000.00/yrCustom-quoted Development+Marketing at ~$500/mo (formerly EveryAction) with multi-channel marketing and advocacy.
Enterprise$1,000.00/mo$12,000.00/yrCustom-quoted Enterprise at $1K+/mo with case management, grants, impact management, API, and dedicated CSM.

Bonterra is the legacy enterprise consolidation platform for nonprofits whose evaluation centers on bundling fundraising plus marketing CRM plus case management plus grants under one parent. Consolidated 2022 by Apax Partners from Network for Good (donor management), EveryAction (multi-channel marketing), and Social Solutions (case management plus grants), Bonterra built around the thesis that enterprise nonprofits running material program operations need fundraising plus marketing plus case management plus grants on one platform.

Three tiers. Guided Fundraising is custom-quoted at ~$159/mo (formerly Network for Good) with donor management and giving plus email plus reports. Development + Marketing CRM is custom-quoted at ~$500/mo (formerly EveryAction) with multi-channel marketing plus advocacy plus events. Enterprise is custom-quoted at $1K+/mo with case management plus grants plus impact management plus API plus dedicated CSM.

The load-bearing wedge is the multi-product enterprise bundle plus the consolidation play. Where Bloomerang, Classy, Givebutter, Donorbox focus on individual segments, Bonterra bundles four legacy products (Network for Good, EveryAction, Social Solutions, plus Bonterra Impact) under one parent; for nonprofits consolidating fundraising plus marketing plus case management plus grants, Bonterra eliminates multiple vendor relationships. The catch is the post-consolidation product roadmap depends on Apax Partners private-equity priorities.

Pros

  • Multi-product enterprise bundle (fundraising plus marketing plus case management plus grants)
  • Network for Good legacy reference base on Guided Fundraising
  • EveryAction multi-channel marketing plus advocacy on Dev+Marketing
  • Case management plus grants plus impact management on Enterprise
  • Strong fit for enterprise nonprofits consolidating multiple vendor relationships

Cons

  • Post-consolidation product roadmap depends on Apax private-equity priorities
  • Custom-quoted across all tiers with multi-product complexity
Guided $159/moDev+Marketing $500/moConsolidated 2022No free tier; Guided custom-quoted entry

Best for: Enterprise nonprofits running material program operations who need fundraising plus marketing plus case management plus grants on one consolidated platform.

Donor data residency
9
Donation processing latency
8
Volunteer plus staff adoption curve
7
Value
7
Support
10
#6

Classy

4.0/10$3,588/yr more

Best peer-to-peer enterprise fundraising with GoFundMe acquisition since 2022

Peer-to-peer enterprise fundraising with GoFundMe acquisition since 2022 and Salesforce native integration.

PlanMonthlyAnnualWhat you get
Essentials$199.00/mo$2,388.00/yrCustom-quoted Essentials at ~$199/mo + 5% transaction with embedded giving and peer-to-peer.
Professional$499.00/mo$5,988.00/yrCustom-quoted Professional at ~$499/mo + 4% transaction with recurring giving and events.
Enterprise$999.00/mo$11,988.00/yrCustom-quoted Enterprise at ~$999+/mo with lower fees, Salesforce native, API, SSO, and dedicated CSM.

Classy is the peer-to-peer enterprise fundraising platform for nonprofits whose evaluation centers on peer-to-peer campaigns plus enterprise Salesforce integration. Founded 2011 in San Diego and acquired by GoFundMe in 2022 for $325M, Classy built around the thesis that enterprise nonprofits should ship peer-to-peer fundraising as the primary product with embedded giving plus events plus recurring giving on one platform.

Three tiers. Essentials is custom-quoted at ~$199/mo + 5% transaction with embedded giving and peer-to-peer plus Salesforce sync. Professional is custom-quoted at ~$499/mo + 4% transaction with recurring giving and events plus branded campaigns. Enterprise is custom-quoted at ~$999+/mo with lower fees, Salesforce native integration, API, SSO, and dedicated CSM.

The load-bearing wedge is the peer-to-peer enterprise focus plus the Salesforce native integration. Where Bloomerang, DonorPerfect, Givebutter, Donorbox, and Kindful focus on donor management with light peer-to-peer, Classy ships peer-to-peer as the primary product that enterprise nonprofits use for walk/run/ride campaigns; for nonprofits running material peer-to-peer events, Classy is the procurement-natural pick. The catch is the platform fee plus transaction percentage compounds above $500K annual giving volume.

Pros

  • Peer-to-peer enterprise focus with branded campaigns
  • Salesforce native integration on Enterprise tier
  • GoFundMe acquisition since 2022 for procurement diligence
  • Recurring giving plus events plus advocacy bundled
  • Strong fit for enterprise nonprofits running material peer-to-peer events

Cons

  • Rebranded as GoFundMe Pro post-2022 acquisition; Classy URL still operates but GoFundMe Pro is the new product name
  • Platform fee plus transaction percentage compounds above $500K annual giving
Essentials $199/moPro $499/moGoFundMe-acquired 2022No free tier; Essentials custom-quoted entry

Best for: Enterprise nonprofits running material peer-to-peer events (walks, runs, rides) wanting Salesforce native integration plus branded campaigns.

Donor data residency
9
Donation processing latency
9
Volunteer plus staff adoption curve
9
Value
7
Support
10
#7

Kindful (Bloomerang-acquired 2021)

2.9/10$2,628/yr more

Best Bloomerang-acquired mid-market donor management since 2021

Bloomerang-acquired mid-market donor management with QuickBooks plus Mailchimp sync since 2021.

PlanMonthlyAnnualWhat you get
Essentials$119.00/mo$1,428.00/yrPer-record Essentials at $119/mo for up to 1k contacts with donor management and QuickBooks plus Mailchimp.
Growth$219.00/mo$2,628.00/yrPer-record Growth at $219/mo for up to 5k contacts with online forms and recurring giving.
Plus$419.00/mo$5,028.00/yrCustom-quoted Plus at $419+/mo for 25k+ contacts with API, integrations, and engagement scoring.

Kindful is the Bloomerang-acquired mid-market donor management platform for nonprofits whose evaluation centers on Bloomerang-backed continuity plus QuickBooks plus Mailchimp sync. Founded 2013 in Nashville and acquired by Bloomerang in 2021, Kindful continues to operate as a standalone product under the Bloomerang parent with the same per-record-tier pricing and integrations; for Kindful customers, the post-acquisition continuity is genuine but procurement teams should diligence whether Kindful eventually merges into the Bloomerang platform.

Three tiers. Essentials is $119/mo for up to 1k contacts with donor management plus giving plus reports and QuickBooks plus Mailchimp sync. Growth is $219/mo for up to 5k contacts with online forms plus recurring giving and custom dashboards. Plus is custom-quoted at $419+/mo for 25k+ contacts with API, advanced integrations, and engagement scoring plus dedicated CSM.

The load-bearing wedge is the Bloomerang-backed continuity plus the QuickBooks plus Mailchimp integration depth. Where Bloomerang ships engagement-scoring native and DonorPerfect ships auction-bundled, Kindful ships QuickBooks plus Mailchimp sync as primary integrations for finance-team plus marketing-team workflows; for nonprofits whose finance team uses QuickBooks and marketing uses Mailchimp, Kindful is the integration-natural pick. The catch is the post-Bloomerang-acquisition roadmap may eventually consolidate Kindful into the Bloomerang platform.

Pros

  • Bloomerang-backed continuity since 2021 acquisition
  • QuickBooks plus Mailchimp sync as primary integrations
  • Per-record published pricing across Essentials and Growth
  • Engagement scoring on Plus tier
  • Strong fit for nonprofits whose finance team uses QuickBooks and marketing uses Mailchimp

Cons

  • Post-Bloomerang-acquisition roadmap may consolidate Kindful into Bloomerang
  • Per-record pricing climbs above 25k contacts
Essentials $119/moGrowth $219/moBloomerang-acquired 2021No free tier; Essentials $119/mo published entry

Best for: Mid-market nonprofits whose finance team uses QuickBooks and marketing uses Mailchimp wanting Bloomerang-backed donor management with native syncs.

Donor data residency
9
Donation processing latency
9
Volunteer plus staff adoption curve
9
Value
8
Support
9

How we picked

Each pick gets a transparent composite score from price, features, free-tier availability, and editor fit. Pricing flows from our live database, so when a vendor changes prices the score updates here too.

Price 40, features 30, free tier 15, fit 15. Donorbox wins composite at 6.28 with $19/mo Pro tier but pinned picks[4] for affordable-online-giving tile claim. Bloomerang pinned picks[0] for head-term mainstream non-profit brand recognition with broadest mid-market reference base since 2012 despite Standard $199 typical.

We don't claim "30,000 hours of testing." Our methodology is the formula above plus the editor's published verdict for each pick. Verifiable, auditable, and updated when the underlying data changes.

Why trust Subrupt

We're a subscription tracker first, a buying guide second. Every claim on this page is something you can check.

By use case

Best mainstream donor management with broadest mid-market base

Bloomerang

Read the full review →

Best peer-to-peer enterprise fundraising with Salesforce sync

Classy

Read the full review →

Best free platform with optional tip-or-fee model

Givebutter

Read the full review →

Best legacy enterprise consolidation with multi-product bundle

Bonterra

Read the full review →

Best affordable online giving with payment-fees-only model

Donorbox

Read the full review →

Didn't make the list

Already in picks (second). Worth flagging the GoFundMe acquisition; enterprise nonprofits running peer-to-peer events get Salesforce native integration plus branded campaigns.

Already in picks (third). Worth flagging the 0% platform fee; SMB nonprofits whose donor base accepts tips get the highest net-to-mission ratio with optional tip funding model.

Already in picks (fifth). Worth flagging the $19/mo Pro; SMB nonprofits with under 1k donors get the cheapest published Pro tier with 0% Donorbox platform fee.

Already in picks (sixth). Worth flagging the bundled auction plus event modules; mid-market nonprofits running material auctions or events get the bundle on Premier $369/mo.

How to choose your Non-Profit Fundraising

Seven product shapes compete for one head term

The 'best non-profit fundraising' search covers seven distinct shapes. Mainstream donor management (Bloomerang) targets mid-market nonprofits with 1k-25k donor records. Peer-to-peer enterprise (Classy) targets enterprise nonprofits running peer-to-peer events. Free platform tip-or-fee (Givebutter) targets SMB nonprofits whose donor base accepts tips. Legacy enterprise consolidation (Bonterra) targets enterprise nonprofits consolidating multi-vendor stacks. Affordable online giving (Donorbox) targets SMB nonprofits with under 1k donors. Per-record priced mid-market (DonorPerfect) targets mid-market with auctions and events. Bloomerang-acquired (Kindful) targets nonprofits on QuickBooks plus Mailchimp. The honest framework: identify your donor database size, fundraising-event mix, and adjacent-vendor consolidation goals before evaluating.

Per-record vs free-platform vs custom-quoted enterprise pricing

Pricing splits into three shapes. Per-record-tier monthly (Bloomerang, DonorPerfect, Kindful) charges $99-$1K/mo with donor-record caps. Free-platform with optional tip-or-fee or transaction-fees-only (Givebutter, Donorbox) ships zero or near-zero monthly fee with optional tips or processing fees. Custom-quoted enterprise (Classy, Bonterra) charges $200-$1K+/mo plus transaction percentage. The honest framework: pick three donor-database scenarios (500, 5K, 25K records), compute monthly cost. Free-platform wins under 500 records; per-record wins at 1K-10K; custom-quoted enterprise wins above 10K with material peer-to-peer or program operations.

The Bonterra 2022 consolidation reshaped legacy enterprise positioning

Bonterra was consolidated in 2022 by Apax Partners from Network for Good (donor management), EveryAction (multi-channel marketing), and Social Solutions (case management plus grants). For Network for Good, EveryAction, or Social Solutions customers, the post-consolidation continuity is genuine but the product roadmap is shaped by Apax private-equity priorities (margin expansion, customer retention) rather than product innovation. The honest framework: evaluate Bonterra as a procurement-safe legacy choice for enterprise nonprofits running multi-product workflows. For greenfield mid-market evaluation, Bloomerang ships better modern UX than the legacy Bonterra products.

When to skip dedicated fundraising platforms and use Stripe Donations plus Google Sheets

Dedicated fundraising platforms are not always the right answer. For very small nonprofits (under 50 donors annually) with simple online giving, Stripe Donations or Stripe Checkout plus Google Sheets for tracking may be sufficient; the engineering plus volunteer-adoption overhead of a dedicated platform is not justified at that scale. For new nonprofits in their first year with limited donor outreach, manual receipts plus Google Sheets work fine. The honest framework: dedicated fundraising platforms fit when donor count exceeds 200 annually or when material peer-to-peer or recurring-giving workflows become load-bearing. Outside that envelope, Stripe Donations plus Google Sheets at low end is often the right answer.

Donor-management-only vs fundraising-only vs all-in-one is genuinely different procurement

The category splits into three product shapes. Donor-management-only (Bloomerang Essentials, DonorPerfect Lite, Kindful Essentials) ships donor CRM as the primary product with light giving forms. Fundraising-only (Donorbox, Givebutter Free) ships online giving forms as the primary product with light donor management. All-in-one (Bloomerang Pro, Classy Enterprise, Bonterra Enterprise) ships donor CRM plus fundraising plus events plus advocacy bundled. The honest framework: pick by primary workflow. Donor-database-heavy nonprofits pick donor-management-only. Online-giving-heavy nonprofits pick fundraising-only. Multi-channel mid-market and enterprise pick all-in-one. The product-shape preference should drive the decision over vendor brand.

Adjacent-vendor consolidation drives 3 of the 7 picks

Three of the seven picks bundle into adjacent vendors or platforms. Classy bundles into GoFundMe ecosystem since the 2022 acquisition. Bonterra consolidated three legacy vendors (Network for Good plus EveryAction plus Social Solutions) into one platform in 2022. Kindful bundles into Bloomerang since the 2021 acquisition. The honest framework: pick by adjacent-vendor relationship. GoFundMe-aware nonprofits pick Classy. Multi-product enterprise nonprofits consolidating legacy stacks pick Bonterra. Bloomerang-curious nonprofits considering both Bloomerang and Kindful pick Bloomerang as the parent (Kindful continues but eventual consolidation is plausible). For nonprofits without adjacent-vendor commitments, Bloomerang or DonorPerfect standalone fit better.

Frequently asked questions

Are these prices guaranteed not to change?

No. Pricing in this category splits into per-record-tier monthly ($99-$1K), free-platform with optional tip-or-fee (Givebutter, Donorbox), and custom-quoted enterprise ($200-$1K+/mo for Classy, Bonterra). Mid-points cited reflect public sticker pricing as of May 2026; vendor pricing changes annually and we refresh on each major shift.

Does Subrupt earn a commission from any of these picks?

We track which picks have approved affiliate programs in our database, and the FTC disclosure block at the top of every guide names which ones currently have a click-tracking partnership. Affiliate revenue does not change ranking. The composite math runs against the same weights for every pick regardless of partnership; if a higher-paying vendor scores worse, it ranks worse. The picks-array order reflects editorial pinning around brand recognition and audience fit.

Why is Bloomerang ranked first when Donorbox wins composite?

Mainstream recognition for non-profit donor management in 2026 is Bloomerang due to broadest mid-market reference base since 2012 and engagement-scoring depth. Bloomerang uniquely matches the mainstream-donor-mgmt tile. Donorbox wins composite math due to $19/mo Pro tier but is narrower in donor management depth. If you are SMB under 1k donors, Donorbox fits better. If you want 0% platform plus tips, Givebutter fits better.

Should I pick Bloomerang or DonorPerfect for mid-market donor management?

Pick by modern UX vs auction-bundle preference. Bloomerang wins for mid-market nonprofits wanting modern UX plus engagement-scoring depth with broadest mid-market reference base since 2012. DonorPerfect wins for mid-market nonprofits running material auctions or events wanting bundled auction-plus-event modules on Premier $369/mo. Different procurement decisions; Bloomerang optimizes for modern donor-management UX, DonorPerfect optimizes for auction-bundle convenience.

When does Givebutter beat Donorbox for free-platform giving?

When your donor base accepts optional tips. Givebutter charges 0% platform fee with optional donor tips funding operations; Donorbox Free charges 1.5% Donorbox fee plus Stripe processing. For nonprofits whose donor base reliably accepts tips, Givebutter delivers higher net-to-mission ratio than Donorbox Free. For nonprofits whose donors decline tips, Donorbox Pro $19/mo (0% platform fee) becomes more economical.

Should I pick Classy or Bonterra for enterprise fundraising?

Pick by single-product peer-to-peer vs multi-product consolidation. Classy wins for enterprise nonprofits running material peer-to-peer events with Salesforce native integration. Bonterra wins for enterprise nonprofits consolidating fundraising plus marketing plus case management plus grants under one parent. Different procurement decisions; Classy optimizes for peer-to-peer depth, Bonterra optimizes for multi-product vendor consolidation.

How do I model the full year-1 non-profit fundraising bill?

Year 1 bill includes platform monthly fee plus payment-processing fees plus integration setup. Bloomerang Standard for 5k records runs ~$2.4K/yr. DonorPerfect Premier runs ~$4.4K/yr. Classy Pro plus 4% txn on $200K giving runs ~$14K/yr. Givebutter Plus runs ~$348/yr. Donorbox Pro runs ~$228/yr plus Stripe. Add QuickBooks plus Mailchimp setup at $1K-$5K. Total year-1 budget ranges $3K to $20K.

Why aren't Salesforce NPSP, Raisers Edge NXT, or NeonCRM in the picks?

Salesforce NPSP is the Salesforce-native nonprofit CRM overlapping Bloomerang for Salesforce-standardized orgs. Raisers Edge NXT (Blackbaud) is the legacy enterprise nonprofit CRM overlapping Bonterra with deeper higher-ed and healthcare reference base. NeonCRM is a mid-market donor management overlapping Bloomerang. We focus on platform-shaped picks with broadest mid-market reference base.

Why aren't Funraise, Virtuous, or Little Green Light in the picks?

Funraise is a peer-to-peer fundraising platform overlapping Classy on P2P wedge with stronger campaign analytics. Virtuous is the modern responsive fundraising platform overlapping Bloomerang on mid-market wedge with stronger automation focus. Little Green Light is an SMB donor management overlapping Bloomerang Essentials on SMB wedge with simpler UX. These options round out the wedge but Bloomerang plus Classy plus Bonterra ship the broadest reference base.

When does this guide get updated?

We aim to refresh /best/ guides quarterly when there are no major shifts, and immediately when there are. Major triggers: Bloomerang Kindful consolidation milestones, Classy GoFundMe roadmap shifts, Givebutter tip-model evolution, Bonterra Apax post-consolidation product roadmap, Donorbox Pro pricing changes, DonorPerfect SofterWare-backed expansions, and AI-fundraising launches that materially shift the category. The lastReviewed date reflects the most recent editorial sweep.

Subrupt Editorial

The team behind subrupt.com. We track subscriptions, surface cheaper alternatives, and publish buying guides where the score formula is on the page so you can recompute it yourself. We do not claim 30,000 hours of testing. What we claim is live pricing from our database, a transparent composite score, and honest savings math against a category baseline.

Last reviewed

Citations

Affiliate disclosure: Subrupt earns a commission when you switch to a service through our recommendation links. This never changes the price you pay. We only recommend services where there's a real cost or feature advantage for you, and our picks are based on the data on this page, not on which programs pay the most.

Related buying guides

Track your subscriptions on Subrupt

Add the Non-Profit Fundraising you pay for and see how much you'd save by switching.

Open dashboard

More buying guides

Independent rankings for the subscriptions worth paying for.

See all guides